Thread:Wikiwalker11291/@comment-6697950-20161108162236

I've noticed that you've added several new references to the weapon list. However, some of them were rather pointless. For example, what point are you trying to achive by referencing V5C4 for the Black Star? The Black Star mention in that chapter is mostly about a real life gun, which isn't really relevant for an article about in-game weapons. There could have been a passing reference about the gun existing in GGO, but just referencing a mention is still rather pointless when we have better references available.

Same goes for Musketeer's EBR. The rifle wasn't even named in the novel, nor given a description other than it was a large rifle. The rifle was only named in Kawahara's tweet, which also fully indicated who used it. So what point is there in referencing the novel?

For the Blue Rose, the prologue only mentioned that the sword exists and was found. It does not even mention that Eugeo took the sword at some point.

Please try to add only relevant references that actually add information about the weapon. Too many pointless references just make it difficult to find where some piece of info came from. For Sword Skills, we add as many references as we can for skills without pages of their own to make it easier to track down all the mentions if we do end up making an article, so more references are better in this case, but most of the weapons that you overreferenced already have articles, so there is no real need to be excessive on the list. 