Board Thread:Editing Discussions/@comment-6697950-20140828085358

Since the first phase of the affiliation voting has been concluded early, it is time to start voting on the second phase: the affiliation criteria.

For this phase, I will list all of the criteria mentioned so far. Each criteria will have a separate vote. Depending on the criteria, it may have more options than just "yes or no". The vote will last until September 5 (Friday), 18:00 (UTC).


 * 1.Series by the same author (basically, Absolute Solitude)
 * Without any requirements
 * Dim1
 * ChaoticShadow
 * C933103
 * WordSniper
 * Must have a set minimum amount of pages
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * Wraiyf (100 pages)
 * 1caiser (100 pages)
 * Reject


 * 2.Gaming genre
 * VR games only (e.g. Log Horizon)
 * Daniel 1939
 * C933103 (or online games)
 * WordSniper (or any video game)
 * Any series which has games as its main focus. (e.g. No Game No Life; Log Horizon)
 * Gsimenas
 * Dim1
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Wraiyf
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * Reject


 * 3.Swords genre (e.g. Seirei)
 * Accept
 * Reject
 * Gsimenas
 * Dim1
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * Wraiyf
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * C933103
 * WordSniper


 * 4.Same label (Dengeki Bunko)
 * Accept
 * WordSniper (100 pages or same author)
 * Reject
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * C933103


 * 5.Same animation studio (e.g. Aldnoah)
 * Accept
 * Daniel 1939
 * C933103
 * Reject
 * TRon69-SAO
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser


 * 6.Same anime season
 * Accept
 * Reject
 * Gsimenas
 * Dim1
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * Wraiyf
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * C933103
 * WordSniper


 * 7.Popular (attracts people)
 * Accept
 * Reject
 * Gsimenas
 * Dim1
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * Wraiyf
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * C933103
 * WordSniper


 * 8.Same main voice actors
 * Accept
 * Reject
 * Gsimenas
 * Dim1
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * Wraiyf
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * C933103


 * 9.Both wikis have common editors (e.g. Seirei; Love Live; No Game No Life)
 * Accept (how many editors should be the minimum?)
 * Gsimenas (at least 3)
 * Dim1
 * Wraiyf
 * C933103 (at least 3 or 33% of the editor base being regulars on both wikis with at least 100 edits and at least 25 edits in the past 6 months)
 * WordSniper (at 33% of the editor base are regulars on both wikis with at least 50 edits in the last year)
 * Reject
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser


 * 10.The series is officially cooperating (or has cooperated in the past) with SAO (e.g. Mahouka due to having a Mahouka and SAO crossover)
 * Accept
 * Gsimenas
 * Dim1
 * TRon69-SAO
 * Daniel 1939
 * Wraiyf
 * ChaoticShadow
 * 1caiser
 * C933103
 * WordSniper (only for crossovers)
 * Reject

More criteria may be suggested on this topic. Each editor has the right to change their vote, but only until the deadline of the voting. Discussions about the criteria may be made on this topic. The voting will be adjusted if new options are suggested. An editor may skip a criteria if they do not have a strong opinion on it.

C9 has also advised using a score-based system. The main voting will continue so that we would have at least one system ready to be used, but discussions about C9's suggestion can be made as an alternative system for affiliations.  